Pakistan’s plan to attract private investment into its power distribution sector has received strong interest from local and foreign investors. However, potential buyers are also asking for important guarantees before they commit their money. One of their main demands is that their returns should be protected against changes in the Pakistani rupee and, in some cases, paid in US dollars.
The issue has come up as Pakistan moves ahead with plans to privatise three major electricity distribution companies, commonly known as DISCOs. The government wants to bring private investment into the sector and improve the way electricity is supplied, managed and collected.
According to officials familiar with discussions with investors, around 12 investors have shown interest in buying the three companies. Four of these potential investors are foreign groups. While the interest is encouraging for the government, investors want clear rules and protection before putting large amounts of money into Pakistan’s power sector.
Why Investors Are Asking for Dollar Payments
The demand for dollar-based returns is mainly linked to currency risk. Investors who bring money into Pakistan worry that the value of their investment could fall if the rupee becomes weaker against the US dollar.
For example, an investor may bring dollars into Pakistan and use them to buy a power distribution company. If the rupee loses value over the years, the money earned by that company in rupees may be worth much less when converted back into dollars.
This is a major concern for foreign investors because they normally measure their investment and expected profit in the currency of their home country or in US dollars.
Investors therefore want some form of protection. They may ask for payments linked to the dollar or for contracts that allow them to recover their investment in a way that protects them from major currency losses.
The issue is not completely new for Pakistan’s energy sector. Many power projects have historically included arrangements linked to foreign currency because investors and lenders need protection from exchange-rate changes.
However, giving similar protection to buyers of distribution companies could create a different challenge because electricity distribution directly affects millions of consumers.
Pakistan Plans to Privatise Three DISCOs
The government has started the process of privatising three power distribution companies in the first phase.
The companies include:
- Faisalabad Electric Supply Company (FESCO)
- Gujranwala Electric Power Company (GEPCO)
- Islamabad Electric Supply Company (IESCO)
These companies are important because they serve large numbers of electricity consumers in their respective areas.
The government hopes that private ownership will bring better management, stronger collection of electricity bills, lower losses and improved services. It also wants to reduce the financial burden on the public sector.
Officials have said that the government is preparing a new system for the companies after privatisation. Investors are being offered attractive returns and greater freedom to operate in a competitive electricity market.
The plan is part of wider efforts to reform Pakistan’s electricity sector, which has struggled for years with high losses, unpaid bills, weak management and financial problems.
Investors Want More Than Just High Returns
Although the government is offering attractive returns, investors are looking beyond the expected profit.
They want confidence that the rules will remain stable after they purchase the companies.
This is especially important because Pakistan’s power sector has seen several policy changes over the years. Contracts and agreements have sometimes been changed or reopened after governments faced financial pressure.
Potential investors are therefore asking for protection against changes that could hurt their businesses.
According to officials, investors have also asked for protection against the reopening or renegotiation of contracts outside agreed control periods.
For investors, a stable agreement is just as important as the expected return. They want to know that the rules agreed at the time of purchase will continue to apply in the future.
Previous Power Sector Decisions Are Affecting Investor Confidence
One reason investors are being careful is Pakistan’s previous experience with independent power producers, or IPPs.
In recent years, the government pushed several IPPs to renegotiate their agreements. Authorities argued that some old contracts placed a heavy financial burden on the country and electricity consumers.
While the government viewed these changes as necessary, investors saw them as a warning about the safety of long-term contracts.
Potential buyers of DISCOs are now seeking stronger protection so that their agreements cannot easily be changed after they invest.
This concern is important because buying a large power company is not a short-term investment. Investors expect to keep their money in the business for many years.
If they believe that a future government could change the rules, reduce returns or reopen agreements, they may demand a higher return to cover the risk.
The Government May Not Accept Dollar Profit Demands
Although investors are asking for dollar-based payments or returns, government officials have indicated that such demands may be difficult to accept.
Paying profits in US dollars could create additional pressure on Pakistan’s foreign exchange reserves.
Pakistan already needs dollars for imports, debt payments, energy purchases and other international obligations. If large power companies also receive their profits directly in dollars, the demand for foreign currency could increase.
Officials have therefore suggested that demands for dollar payments or exemptions from purchasing electricity from IPPs are unlikely to be accepted in their current form. Such arrangements could have a direct impact on consumers and the wider economy.
This puts the government in a difficult position.
On one side, Pakistan needs private investment to improve the electricity sector. On the other side, it cannot easily agree to every demand made by investors if those demands create additional pressure on the economy.
Why the Rupee Issue Matters So Much
The Pakistani rupee has faced major pressure over the past several years. Exchange-rate changes can have a big impact on businesses that have foreign investment or foreign loans.
Imagine an investor puts $100 million into a Pakistani company when the exchange rate is Rs300 per dollar. The investment would equal about Rs30 billion at that rate.
If the rupee later falls to Rs400 per dollar, the same $100 million would equal Rs40 billion.
For a foreign investor, this means that simply earning money in rupees may not be enough. The investor also needs to consider how much that income will be worth when converted into dollars.
This is why currency protection can become a major part of investment negotiations.
For Pakistan, however, providing full dollar protection can increase the country’s foreign exchange requirements. The government must therefore find a balance between protecting investors and protecting the economy.
Investors Also Want a Stable Regulatory System
Currency is not the only concern.
Potential buyers also want clear rules for operating the distribution companies after privatisation.
The electricity sector is highly regulated. Distribution companies deal with tariffs, power purchases, electricity theft, line losses, consumer complaints and payment collection.
A private investor needs to know how these matters will be handled before deciding how much to pay for a company.
Investors have reportedly raised concerns about what will happen after privatisation and how the market will operate.
The government has said it is willing to address genuine concerns related to the post-privatisation market system. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has also instructed the Privatisation Commission to prepare a transparent and rule-based framework for the period after privatisation.
This could help improve investor confidence if the new system is clear and remains stable over time.
Why Pakistan Wants Private Investment
Pakistan’s electricity distribution system has been facing financial and operational problems for years.
Public-sector companies have struggled with electricity theft, unpaid bills, technical losses and weak collection systems. These problems increase the financial burden on the government.
When distribution companies fail to recover the full cost of electricity supplied to consumers, the losses eventually affect the wider economy.
Private investors are expected to bring better management practices and stronger systems for collecting bills and reducing losses.
A successful privatisation programme could therefore help improve electricity services while reducing the amount of money the government has to spend supporting loss-making companies.
The government is also hoping that private owners will invest in technology, improve customer service and reduce electricity losses.
The Debt Problem Adds More Pressure
Pakistan’s public-sector power companies also operate in an environment where debt and unpaid liabilities remain a major concern.
According to officials cited in recent reports, the debt and liabilities of public-sector enterprises increased by 8.7 percent during the last fiscal year, reaching around Rs3.11 trillion. That was an increase of Rs249 billion in one year.
Such numbers show why the government wants private investors to take a larger role in the sector.
If private owners can operate the companies more efficiently, the government could reduce some of the financial pressure created by poorly performing public-sector businesses.
However, investors will not take on these companies without carefully studying their financial position.
They will want to understand existing debts, liabilities, electricity losses, customer payments and future investment needs before finalising any deal.
Consumers Are Also Part of the Debate
Any agreement between the government and private investors will ultimately affect electricity consumers.
If investors receive dollar-linked returns, the government may need to find a way to cover those payments without putting too much additional pressure on consumers.
Higher costs could eventually be reflected in electricity tariffs.
This is why officials are cautious about accepting every demand made by potential buyers.
Pakistan needs investment, but it also needs affordable electricity for households, businesses and industries.
A system that gives investors strong returns but increases electricity costs too much could create another problem for the economy.
Investors Want Confidence Before Committing Money
The latest discussions show that investors are interested in Pakistan, but they are also carefully studying the risks.
The fact that about 12 investors, including four foreign groups, have shown interest suggests that there is still appetite for investment in the country’s electricity sector.
At the same time, their demands show that investors want stronger protection.
They want to know that their contracts will be respected, that rules will not suddenly change and that currency risks will be managed fairly.
These concerns are understandable because the purchase of a large electricity company involves a major amount of money and a long-term commitment.
Pakistan Faces a Difficult Balancing Act
The government now has to find a middle path.
It needs to make the DISCOs attractive enough for investors while ensuring that the final agreements do not create a heavy burden on consumers or Pakistan’s foreign exchange position.
A transparent system could be the key.
If investors receive clear rules, fair treatment and reasonable protection, they may be more willing to invest without demanding excessive guarantees.
At the same time, the government needs to make sure that consumers are protected from unnecessary increases in electricity costs.
The success of the DISCO privatisation programme will depend heavily on how well this balance is managed.
What This Could Mean for Pakistan’s Power Sector
If the privatisation process goes ahead successfully, Pakistan could see major changes in the way electricity distribution companies are managed.
Private ownership could encourage companies to focus more strongly on reducing losses, improving bill collection and providing better services.
It could also reduce the financial pressure on the government.
However, privatisation alone will not solve every problem. Strong regulation, fair electricity pricing, better transmission systems and action against electricity theft will still be needed.
The government must also maintain investor confidence over the long term. If agreements are changed repeatedly, future investors may become less interested in Pakistan.
Final Thoughts
The demand for dollar payments from potential buyers of Pakistan’s power distribution companies highlights one of the biggest challenges facing the government: attracting foreign and local investment while protecting the country’s economy.
Investors want protection from currency losses and changes in government policy. They are also asking for guarantees that their contracts will not be reopened without proper reasons.
Pakistan, meanwhile, has to consider the impact of these demands on foreign exchange reserves, electricity prices and consumers.
The government has shown that it is willing to listen to genuine investor concerns and is working on a clear post-privatisation framework. However, demands such as direct dollar payments or special exemptions may be difficult to accept because of their possible impact on the wider economy.
The interest shown by around 12 potential investors is still a positive sign. It suggests that investors see opportunities in Pakistan’s power distribution market. The next challenge is to create agreements that give investors enough confidence while ensuring that ordinary electricity consumers do not carry an unfair burden.
If Pakistan can build a stable, transparent and balanced system, the DISCO privatisation process could become an important step toward improving the country’s troubled power sector.
Read Also: check
